Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

25 Kislev 5765 - December 8, 2004 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

Opinion & Comment
Politica: Sharon's Phased Plan

By E. Rauchberger

Ariel Sharon plans to set up a new government within the next two weeks. "A state cannot be run without a government," he said, and rightfully so. The State and the government have already been hobbling along for too long with a paralyzed minority government. The sooner this comes to an end the better.

According to the first phase of the plan, to assemble a new coalition the Labor Party and United Torah Jewry will be brought in along with MKs Tal and Nudelman and perhaps Paritzky ("the three loners," as they are dubbed in the Knesset). Such a government would number 66-69 MKs—40 from the Likud, 21 from Labor, 5 from UTJ and the loners. In the second phase, after this government stabilizes, Shas' turn will come. Sharon will save the party two portfolios, one high-level portfolio and one lesser portfolio. If and when Shas joins the government could total 80 MKs.

The plan to bring in Shas only later stems from its opposition to the disengagement plan and Sharon's difficult experiences with the party. UTJ's vote against the disengagement plan was primarily for tactical reasons, while Shas's no-vote was ideological and electoral.

At a recent Likud meeting Sharon made clear that any party that did not support the disengagement plan would not join the government. Shimon Peres also announced he had no intentions of joining a government with parties opposed to the disengagement plan (read: Shas).

Under such circumstances Shas' demands would be reduced to a minimum, especially in the area of socioeconomics. From Shas' standpoint the issue of disengagement would be solved if Sharon met with Abu Mazzen to tell him he is going from a unilateral to a bilateral track. But such a meeting would not take place before the PA elections in another four weeks and Sharon cannot wait that long to set up a stable government, which he must do as soon as possible.

Eventually Labor Will Arrive

Neither was the work of bringing in the Labor Party a simple matter, although on paper it looked easy. Labor is highly complex internally. It has more leaders than followers and the addition of Ehud Barak into the race for party leadership merely adds fuel to the fire.

Not everyone in the Labor Party wants to join a unity government. Peres can expect a stiff battle over a decision to join the government. First he will have to gain the approval of party entities.

Ehud Barak and his faction are staunchly opposed to joining the government. They claim the party can support the government from outside the coalition to implement the disengagement plan and to reach an agreement with Sharon to hold elections approximately one year from now after the disengagement is complete.

Matan Vilnai is also vying for the post of party chairman. Having recently won popularity in surveys of Labor voters he is unexcited over the prospects of a unity government. Unlike Barak he does agree Labor should join the government, but for just a single reason: to pass the disengagement plan. Thus the day after the disengagement plan has been implemented Labor must leave the government and call for new elections.

But Vilnai and Barak share some common ground: both are concerned joining a unity government would delay the plan to hold party elections and both are eager to contend for the title of party chairman.

After the battle over joining the government the time will come for another battle with Labor over ministerial appointments. More than 10 Labor MKs, over half the party, see themselves as worthy candidates for ministerial posts— Shimon Peres, Binyamin Ben Eliezer, Matan Vilnai, Ephraim Sneh, Chaim Ramon, Beigah Shochat, Shalom Simchon, Dalia Itzik, Amram Mitzna, Ophir Pines, Yitzchok Herzog and Ehud Barak (who is not an MK).

According to the agreement between Sharon and Peres, Labor will receive 6-7 portfolios. Four are guaranteed places: Peres, Ben Eliezer, Vilnai and Itzik. Simchon's place also looks quite secure as the representative of settlement. From Peres' perspective the two other ministers are Mitzna and Ramon and in any case Ehud Barak will not make the list.

But if the list of ministers is determined by secret ballot at party headquarters Ramon will have no chance and Mitzna will have to fight for his position. On the other hand Barak, Sneh and perhaps even Pines will have far greater chances. Shochat and Herzog will have to satisfy themselves with the knowledge they were even candidates for ministerial posts.


All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.