Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

25 Kislev 5765 - December 8, 2004 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Home and Family

Why are we Choking Ourselves?
by Raizel Foner

"Why are we choking ourselves?!"

Miri almost dropped the pot she was washing. "What are you talking about, Dovid? You're choking? You don't feel well?"

Dovid rolled the corner of the page of figures he was working on and gritted his teeth. "We just made a bar mitzva last year for Zev. Why are we making a bar mitzva now for Rifka?"

"Rifky? Dovid, are you sure you're O.K.? Rifki is getting married. She's not having a bar mitzva. You know that."

"Then why are we renting the same hall that we rented for Zev's bar mitzva?"

Miri looked searchingly at Dovid, then spoke slowly. "We're renting the hall for Rifky's vort."

"What for?"

"Dovid, what do you think? For the neighbors to come and wish us `Mazel Tov.' "

Dovid rubbed his beard and sighed. "Do we really have to do this? I'm going through the figures here for putting together the wedding and seeing what we can come up with to help Rifky and her chosson start to set up their new home. Everything costs... A lot. If we could cut out the non- essentials, we'd have less to borrow to pay for the things we really need. Can't the neighbors just call us up and wish us `Mazel Tov'? Or maybe they could say it to us at the wedding."

"But everyone makes an engagement party," Miri said, somewhat doubtfully.

Dovid sighed again. "Miri, we're not living our lives. We're living other people's expectations."

They were both silent. Then Miri cleared her throat, stating rather than asking, "This is probably the wrong time to talk about Zev getting a new suit, isn't it."

"But Zev hasn't grown much since his bar mitzva. Why does he need a new suit?"

Miri coughed. "Um, he says that now the style is black with these thin white lines."

"You're right, Miri. This is the wrong time to talk about it, or maybe it isn't... I don't understand. Since when should yeshiva boys be interested in styles? I can understand that they need to look respectable and have clean, ironed shirts, but whose idea is it to change styles?

"When our children were born, I happily accepted the responsibility to pay for their food and clothing, their tuition and medical expenses. What I have a problem with is shelling out money for the `We don't need it but it seems like everyone else is buying it' category. I just can't fathom it, Miri. We Bnei Torah are supposed to be as intelligent as the general population. Why, then, are we acting so irrationally?"

"You mean keeping up with changing styles?"

"Yes, that's part of it. I do wonder why for Rivky's wedding Esty can't wear what Rivky wore to her cousin's wedding."

"But Dovid, that was six years ago! True, the sizes are the same but no one wears that style nowadays."

"So?"

"Well, we don't want to look cheap."

"I am not being cheap," Dovid said with dignity. "I am trying to be economical, to live within our means so that we can continue to provide our children with necessities like food, without sinking into debt. If it means forgoing some fluffy little extras and setting an example for other people of how not to go overboard, so be it."

The phone rang merrily and while Dovid went to answer, Miri finished the dishes and started going through the local directory for names and numbers of whom to invite. Certainly to the wedding. As for the vort...

Dovid returned a few minutes later. "That was our future mechuton. He was very apologetic, but wanted us to know that on Sunday night he gives a shiur, Monday night he has a very important chavrusa, on Tuesday night he learns with his sons and on Wednesday... Well, you get the picture. I don't know if he's short on money — and who isn't before a wedding — but he is short on time. I told him that if he wants, we can skip the vort." Dovid chuckled. "He couldn't stop thanking us."

"So that's it? No eirusin?"

"Tell me, do you really have the time to do all the baking and phone calls and preparations for it?"

"I guess not. Last year, I wasn't working, so I was able to do Zev's bar mitzva, but this year..."

"You know, Miri, I think we're doing the neighbors a favor, too. There is so much going on at night in our community — PTA meetings, shiurim, fundraising events, bar mitzvas and so on. Why pressure people to squeeze in an unnecessary night out?"

"What do you mean `unnecessary?' "

"Because we hope they'll be coming to the wedding! Why make them shlep out again?"

"O.K. So what's next on the agenda?"

[Raizel gave the editor two choices of endings, one of them being the idea of a wedding in a park. Miri and I both discredited this as a winter option. Having passed the first hurdle, though, we will let the subject rest for the meanwhile and have the `last vort.']

 

All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.