Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

16 Iyar 5765 - May 25, 2005 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

POPULAR EDITORIALS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Home and Family

Do You Remember?
by A. Ross, M.Ed

Most siblings fight or at least disagree to some extent, during childhood. My brother and I were no exception. Now, looking back, we cannot even remember what those fierce fights were all about. However, we still disagree about what happened in our youth. I might say it was mid-summer and the sun was shining during a particular event, whereas he will be convinced that there was deep snow on the ground. He may remember an event quite clearly, in all its details, while I have no recollection of it at all, and vice versa.

As soon as a child can see, and form impressions, events are imprinted on his mind. People often say in answer to an older child's question, "Oh, you can't possibly remember, you were too young." Some interesting research was carried out in the U.S. In their first week of life, newborns were given a few drops of glucose. In one group, the drops were preceded by soft gently strokes on the baby's forehead. The control group received just the glucose, without the accompanying petting. After some days, the first group of babies was petted in the usual way, without receiving any drops. Each baby showed his disappointment vociferously! The control group did not cry as they were stroked. This is a form of memory which is purely physical; animals can be trained in the same way, but it does show that memory is there from birth.

During the first five years of his development, the child is gathering information and experiences, which are accompanied by various impressions. He will not always be able to draw on this memory, especially if it was an unpleasant experience, but it will be in his subconscious. Frequently, it happens that an older child tells of an experience from when he was two years old or even less, which he could not possibly remember. Someone must have told him about it. On the other hand, if a child is really articulate at the age of two, then his thought processes are more sophisticated. If he has sufficient vocabulary to speak about the event at the age when it occurs, then he may well remember it.

It is important to give an honest reply to children's questions. They need the answers to complete their impressions. Short, simple answers are sufficient for small children. A small boy used to visit an old lady regularly. After she died, he went to visit the unmarried children who lived in the house, and was extremely upset that she had gone to Heaven without her chair. The following week, the chair was gone and this four-year-old did not ask where it was. Years later, he told me that he just assumed that they had sent it to her and she was sitting on it in Shomayim.

Children listen to everything the omnipotent adults around them say, and absorb it all. If Mummy says she is short of money, or can't afford a particular item, a small child could worry for months about whether there is enough money for food Even flippant remarks which mean nothing at all, will be thrown back at the speaker weeks later. "But you said that." There are true stories of children whose parents were highly embarrassed when their remarks were repeated. Like the little girl who opened the door to an unloved aunt and said, "Daddy will be so happy to see you. Last time you came he said it was all he needed, that Aunty Yente should visit." Some children acquire a terrible fear of Purim. The masks unnerve some children and the frightening unpleasant memory remains with them for years. In fact, some phobias evolve from unpleasant memories. A woman I know has a deep rooted fear of fireworks, which stems from the memory of a firework exploding under a child's pram when she herself was a small girl. If you know that a child is going to have an unpleasant experience, tell him about it beforehand. There is no point in saying that a visit to the dentist won't hurt, if you know that the child needs treatment. Explain that it might hurt but not for too long and that you will stand there all the time to hold his hand. Without this, if a child has been told that it won't hurt, first of all, he will lose faith in his mother, secondly, he may develop an unhealthy fear of the dentist.

There are unavoidable events for which we cannot prepare the child, and then it depends on the way we handle it, how they will remain in the child's mind. If we force ourselves to react calmly, it might not even become a memorable event, for instance, if a dog jumps up playfully while you are in the park. You may be petrified of dogs, yourself, but if you want to prevent the phobia from passing on to your children, say calmly that the dog is only playing. No harm will come to any of you and it won't become a memorable event. (I can almost hear readers' protests!) The aforementioned brother does not remember how he used to approach the two dogs on the farm where we lived, with his teeth chattering, determined to overcome his fear. We still remember the dogs' names but one sibling says they were large dogs, and the other says they were small scotch terriers!

In the 'olden days,' when many women had their babies at home, a man smelt some Dettol disinfectant. He remarked instinctively 'it smells of new babies'. There are literally hundreds of smells which conjure up memories, pleasant or otherwise. Tunes will also bring back very early memories. Facial expressions with all the nuances will remind adults or older children of earlier events.

Parents always have to be careful in what they say or do not say, and because they are `writing on fresh paper,' it leaves an indelible imprint. One thing is sureċif you say something wrong, or something which you later regret, the child will remember it forever. Teachers have found that out to their cost. It is very difficult to 'unteach' a wrong fact.

Rabbi Elisha Ben Abuya likens one who teaches a child, to someone writing in ink on a fresh sheet of paper. Everything is an experience and a source of wonder to the child and is filed in his memory. "Who wanted to put me in the bin, in our holiday house?" asked a six year old. The mother was mystified and wondered what had happened in the summer. It seems that there had been a notice on the beach 'refuse to be put into the bins provided'. The child had been contemplating the idea for months till he asked for an explanation. Children's minds are not so preoccupied with extraneous tasks and worries. They have time to wonder and ponder, which is a reason why they remember trivial events more easily. They do not always react immediately, but everything is retained.

The Chofetz Chaim relates the story of an elderly man who describes the visit of the Russian Czar in every detail. Seventy years later, the oldster recalled the coachman's uniform, his rosy cheeks, what the Czar himself wore, and all the minutiae of the horse-drawn carriage. Yet if you ask him now what a particular person whom he just met wore, he will answer that he didn't notice. It was not important to him. Rabbi Yehoshua's mother put his cradle into the Beis Midrash so that the infant would imbibe words of Torah. Some people are blessed with a good memory, others have to cultivate it. We are told about Rebbi Elozor, whose memory was like a cement cistern, that he cultivated it, trained it never to forget a word of the Torah he learned.

Help your children remember the right things, doubly so if they are born with a retentive memory.

 

All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.