Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

1 Kiselv 5767 - November 22, 2006 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

POPULAR EDITORIALS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Home and Family

Are you Mesmerized by Hypnosis
by A. Ross

Hypnosis is a state in which consciousness and will are suspended, but other functions are not impaired. The subject is then extremely susceptible to suggestion and will carry out orders at once, or long after being awakened. In the late eighteenth century, an Austrian physician, Mesmer, claimed that he could reduce people to trance state, and subordinate their will-power to his. He was expelled by the police from Vienna, but created a sensation in Paris with his public demonstrations of stage hypnosis; yet seven years later, he was denounced as a charlatan. These early experiments in hypnosis, were formerly called mesmerism, after him.

In the mid-nineteenth century, a Manchester surgeon by the name of James Braid, realized that the human imagination played a much greater role in the process of hypnotism than did any physical forces or than the ability of the hypnotist. It was Braid who coined the new name, after the Greek word 'sleep'.

We see what a person does under hypnosis, but nobody has really explained why he does it. We know that it is a trance state, characterized by relaxation, extreme suggestibility, and heightened imagination. It is not really like sleep, because the person is alert the whole time. He is fully conscious, but tunes out most of the surrounding stimuli, focusing intently on the subject in hand, to the exclusion of any other thought. It can be compared to losing oneself in a book, or watching a film on a screen (which is why computers can be so harmful, they hypnotise the watcher), or even plain day dreaming.

One recent researcher maintained that people hypnotize themselves on a daily basis. For instance, when one is engrossed in a book, one can experience real happiness, anxiety or fear, and even be reduced to tears. Normally, the subconscious looks after all the things one does automatically. It does all our thinking and passes messages on to the brain. Whether we are driving a car, baking a cake, changing a baby or mending a fuse, the subconscious mind puts all the little things together, and works in conjunction with the conscious.

Hypnotists who induce the 'trance' state, try to access a person's subconscious mind. In this way, the conscious mind will not inhibit his behavior: it will not put the brakes on unacceptable conduct. Thus a hypnotic subject who is normally very reserved, might crow like a cock in front of hundreds of people, or act in a completely uncharacteristic way, because the conscious mind is not filtering through with caution. However, our subconscious has a conscience, survival instincts and its own ideas. There are many things it will not agree to do: in fact, nobody can be made to do what he does not want to!

Stage hypnosis was banned more than fifty years ago, although charlatans are still practicing hypnosis privately. How is hypnosis used nowadays? The subconscious is the storehouse for all memories. While under hypnosis, subjects may be able to access past events which they have completely forgotten. Psychiatrists may use hypnotism to bring up these memories, to solve a personal problem. For example, a friend of mine was overeating regularly, and putting on far too much weight. The hypnotist dredged up a memory of how, as a child, her mother had given her a plate of food and told her countless times what a good girl she was for eating it all up. The practitioner convinced her to take less on her plate, and always to leave a little.

As the subject is so suggestible, hypnotists might create false memories. Thus in forensic hypnotism, the evidence is not widely accepted.

Hypnotism is a powerful tool for reversing bad habits. Smoking, bed wetting and nail biting have all been cured by hypnosis. However, when therapists work with a whole group, the results are not always successful, nor very long lasting.

Although it is still a controversial subject, the success of medical hypnotherapy is undeniable. Doctors claim that hypnotic suggestion can ease pain, and even cure illness in some patients.. When they suggest to the subconscious that the body is free from disease, or that it does not feel pain, the subconscious might actually bring about the change. Many cancer patients swear by hypnosis, claiming that it helps manage the pain and discomfort of chemo therapy. Thousands of women make it through childbirth with minimum discomfort with the aid of hypnosis. None of these reported improvements have been proved by clinical trials, the evidence is purely anecdotal, which is why so many people are sceptical, or frankly, disbelieving.

Skeptics argue that hypnotic subjects are not really in a trance state, they only think they are. A good hypnotist is someone with strong enough authority and charisma to convince you to obey him. The influence of the hypnotist is enough to convince a person that he should act in a certain way. As soon as the person feels he is obeying the suggestion, he thinks he must be in a trance. If you think someone is forcing you to act in a certain way, you will act that way.

The same applies to a placebo in medicine. Most people who are given a sugar pill and are told that it is an especially strong pain killer, will begin to feel less pain after half an hour. However, in the end, this theory is not really different from the 'trance theory.' It is immaterial whether it is imagination, or a trance. When a person is told with firm conviction that you have brought about a change in his subconscious, he will believe you, and act accordingly. So even though no change has been brought about, and it is just in his imagination, the result is the same, and hypnotic suggestions can change his whole ideas.

Methods vary, but all hypnosis depends on three things. 1.The subject must want to be hypnotized. If the person does not cooperate, hypnotism will not work. 2. The subject must believe in hypnotism. He or she must be convinced that s/he is able to be hypnotized. 3. Eventually, the subject must feel relaxed and comfortable.

If these conditions are met, there are several methods used to induce a hypnotic trance. The one most commonly known is the 'fixed gaze' method; this is when the hypnotist waves an object slowly in front of the subject's eyes, while simultaneously speaking slowly and soothingly. The aim is to get the subject to focus on the object so intently that he tunes out all other stimuli.

Then there is the 'rapid' method: when the hypnotist overloads the subject's mind with sudden, firm commands, in rapid succession. If the commands are forceful enough, and if the hypnotist is convincing enough, the subject will give up his conscious control over the situation, and will accept any suggestions the hypnotist makes.

The method most commonly used nowadays by psychiatrists is 'progressive relaxation and imagery.' The hypnotist brings the subject into a state of complete relaxation and focus, by speaking slowly and soothingly, without waving any objects in front of his eyes.

Finally, there is 'loss of equilibrium.' This method uses slow, rhythmic, rocking movements, to create a loss of balance. Parents have been using this method on their babies since time immemorial.

There are advertisements by 'Certified Hypnotists' that they can help you lose weight, stop smoking or overeating, biting your nails or cure you of any other bad habits. What is a certified hypnotist? There really is no official body which sanctions practitioners, as there is for doctors, dentists or teachers, for example. It is a fact that anyone who has taken a course for a couple of hours can call himself certified. Some of these people have very high standards, but others are quacks, who extract money from unsuspecting customers.

If you do want to use the services of a hypnotist, take care! Their ideas are not always the same as ours. Finally, do not leave a child alone with a hypnotist who does not share our beliefs, even though he claims he can cure him of wetting the bed, or of any other disturbing habit.

 

All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.