Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

11 Teves 5766 - January 11, 2006 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

POPULAR EDITORIALS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

Opinion & Comment
Talmidim Are Sons, Teachers Are Fathers

by Rav Yehoshua Sklar

Rashi in parshas Voeschanon (6:6) teaches us a wonderful idea. The posuk says, "And you shall teach them to your sons." Talmidim are always referred to as "sons" — the posuk says, "you are Hashem's . . . sons" (Devorim 14:1) [which in terms of our relationship with Hashem can only mean disciples].

In the same way that talmidim are called "sons," the teacher is called "father," as the posuk says [quoting Elisha's cry when he witnessed the ascent of his mentor Eliyohu Hanovi to Heaven], "Father, Father, chariot of Yisroel!" (Melochim II 13:14).

Rashi is telling us that a rebbe is more than a teacher; he's a teacher and a father together. Rav Yechezkel Sarna zt'l, the rosh yeshiva of Chevron, would frequently remark that yeshiva students are termed bnei hayeshiva i.e. the yeshiva's sons and their teachers are their fathers. He would explain the above Rashi wonderfully, asking why the first posuk doesn't explicitly say, "And you shall teach them to your talmidim"? He explained that a rebbe must feel that his talmidim are his own sons. The type of character that the Torah seeks in a teacher is someone whose talmidim will feel is like their father. This lesson is imparted by calling talmidim "sons."

There is an additional nuance to Rashi's words, " . . .the teacher is called a father." The father-son relationship is an everlasting one. There's no such thing as temporary fatherhood. Teachers and educators too, remain their disciples' "fathers" forever. A father never stops thinking about what is good for his son.

The implication of all is that we ought to be feeling joy at the sight of our sons going to their yeshivos and places of learning — this one to yeshiva ketanoh, that one to yeshiva gedolah. They run off joyfully with their seforim back to chadorim and botei medrash like sons going home, for going home they are, back to their "father's" home. Their parents' hearts are filled with hope and longing for their precious sons' complete success.

As we noted, a teacher is like a father and he remains so forever. It is important for a teacher to maintain contact with a talmid who is finishing his studies in talmud Torah and moving to yeshiva ketanoh, or completing yeshiva ketanoh and going to yeshiva gedolah. The talmid might be experiencing difficulties with chavrusas or with friends in general. Such "teething troubles" are common at the beginning of an Elul zman when entering a new environment.

Problems of this type have often almost broken the spirits of new talmidim in yeshivos ketanos and gedolos. When a bochur receives a letter of good wishes and encouragement right at the beginning of the zman from his teacher and mentor, or even if he can approach the teacher when he feels it necessary, it can do wonders for his morale.

It is not our intention here to demand, or even to ask teachers to do this; it is merely a request that they rise to the challenge. Particularly at the beginning of the zman, a bochur's new maggid shiur or mashgiach will not always know his character and sensitivities. How crucial can be a good word from a teacher who has known the boy for several years! It is so important to have occasional get-togethers of the previous year's graduation class with their old teachers, to hear their words of inspiration. They were close to these teachers as youngsters throughout the years that they studied under them.

*

I wish to mention two instructive things on this subject. During the first years that I worked for Chinuch Atzmai, between 5718-27, I instituted an important custom in order to keep a firm connection with talmidim who had been directed to yeshivos kedoshos in the framework of the Keren Sha'os Toranios program.

At the beginning of Elul, I sent each talmid a fine greeting card, nicely designed and incorporating a delicate flower, containing good wishes for his success in his new place of study. The letters were sent to each one's address at his yeshiva. The extent of the encouragement that this modest little card provided cannot be described. In addition, it contributed to friendships among those who have in the meantime become grandfathers and still maintain these friendships.

A teacher of our eighth grades recently told me that he sent invitations to his son's wedding to his old students. With tears in his eyes he said that virtually all of them responded and came to share his happiness. He was their "father" and remained so. They felt this and came to join their "father" on his joyous occasion.

When discussing the importance of spiritual mentors' encouragement, it is even more important that the students' real fathers don't forget that they remain fathers forever, even when their sons are in yeshiva. When their sons go off to a new place of learning, parents must make them aware of the importance of maintaining contact with the maggid shiur and the mashgiach. It is important that parents pay attention to everything they hear from maggid shiur and mashgiach and it is important that the bochur himself hears it.

Our sons can be compared to trees that grow and sprout from their roots. Every word of encouragement and prodding generates another root that facilitates a ben Torah's growth. We who belong to the older generation were nurtured by our teachers zy'a who, during their lives, encouraged and guided the youth of their day.

Our master the Chazon Ish felt like a "father" to all the bnei yeshiva of his time. He lavished love and encouragement on them, both verbal and written. He sent letters to bochurim when they were starting out in learning. As they continued, if he heard that a bochur's spirits were low he would send off letters full of encouragement and feeling, phrased in his refined and noble style, as we find in Igros Chazon Ish, vol. I.

I would like to quote here from two letters.

"You are still in your formative years and it is in your power to take your place among men of virtue and elevation. You have the opportunity to acquire Torah wisdom, the empowerment of life on the earth . . . Please, do not view yourself as being beyond hope or [the task] as being too difficult for you, for while all beginnings are hard, no obstacle can withstand willpower and a person who strives to purify himself receives Heavenly assistance. The main thing is to make a resolution and not to retreat because of the obstacles that are encountered at the beginning of the road to purity . . ." (Vol. I, letter 17)

"I received your letter and was extremely happy to see you delving into Torah. Continue applying yourself to constant Torah study and try to climb ever higher each day with great energy, absorbing divrei Torah in your heart and soul, for this is man's entire purpose.

"With regard to what you wrote, it is a possibility; perhaps it would be right for you to come and speak it over . . ."

What encouragement these words of the godol hador contain, especially the second letter, in which the Chazon Ish zy'a doesn't make do with writing but invites the bochur personally, "perhaps it would be right for you to come and speak it over . . ."

Perhaps this will lead the spiritual "fathers" of bochurim to follow in our teachers' footsteps and write now and then to a bochur who could use a few words of encouragement. If so, that would be our reward.


All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.