Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

11 Tishrei 5763 - September 17, 2002 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

Opinion & Comment
This Year in Politics

by E. Rauchberger

Unlike many previous years, 5762 is a relatively easy year to summarize. Although there was plenty of political activity, it can all be summed up in six letters: Sharon. He dominated the entire Israeli political scene throughout last year, leaving almost no room for anyone else.

Over the course of the year Sharon presented himself as the country's most seasoned politician, sweeping all others out of the way. His achievements in this vein were unmatched, certainly in the recent past. After having weathered numerous political battles, in 5762 Sharon outdid himself, reaching the peak of his career. When he was ousted from his post as Defense Minister twenty years ago following the Lebanese War and seen as "muktzeh machmas mi'us" by the general public, who would have dreamed he would rebound and reach the heights of Israeli politics, becoming a prime minister with tremendous power and influence?

Sharon was elected in the middle of 5761. The first half of the year-and-a-half since he took office was less stellar, but the latter three-fourths of 5762 proved a more fruitful period for him. In 5761 he was still hesitant, lacking self- confidence. But in 5762 the Sharon of legend came out of his shell, the Sharon who does what he pleases, without pandering to other people's whims.

His decision to launch Operation Defensive Shield was undoubtedly a turning point. It won tremendous public backing and its relative success generated widespread confidence in him. The encirclement of Arafat in Ramallah and the crushing of the Palestinian Authority further boosted his reputation.

Sharon won massive support in public surveys, particularly in the second half of the year. Today he regularly garners the support of 60 percent of respondents, sometimes as much as 70 percent and even more, figures far exceeding any posted by his peers in recent years. This level of backing may be common in some other countries, but in Israel it is almost unheard of.

True, terrorist attacks were not halted completely by Israel's military activities, but beyond a doubt the number of attacks has dropped sharply, a reduction credited to the Prime Minister. The public clearly perceives Sharon as not stuck in a rut, but constantly seeking new solutions to the problem of terrorism and fighting it with all of the means at his disposal.

Meanwhile he has also managed to steer policy in a manner that increases confidence. Time after time he has repeated statements that he is interested in peace and a political solution, which he has even described on some occasions, while letting out the reins a bit to various (Labor party) figures who are especially involved in the political process. He has been wary not to pick too many fights with Shimon Peres, allowing him to meet with Palestinians and advance various plans, up to a certain point. Sharon is smart enough to know that everything will eventually be placed on his table for final approval, so he has little to lose by allowing Peres to play around with conjecture ("It seems to me . . . ") and supposition, and Sharon can collect the political dividends.

The Prime Minister has also succeeded in building great relations with US President George W. Bush and the rest of the US top-ranking political echelon. Sharon has received just about all the support he has asked the United States to provide. Israel could not expect any greater sympathy and support from the US. Washington backed the Israeli position vis-a-vis the Palestinians every step of the way, and all of the credit went to Sharon.

He and his staff invested great efforts into marketing the Israeli position it to the Americans. Sharon himself flew to the US six times during the year to meet with President Bush, in addition to phone calls with him and conversations and meetings with the Secretary of State, the National Security Advisor, the Secretary of Defense, the Vice President and others.

The backing he received from the US helped considerably. Without it Sharon would not have been able to win such widespread popularity and support at home. He shrank the local Left down to size, largely thanks to the US support.

The only issue to cast a shadow over Sharon's popularity was the economy. Both economic and social affairs have shown steady declines during the past year. Although Sharon cut budget allocations and allowances, these cuts did not help much. The public was still disappointed in this area, and when Shas and UTJ voted against him following the cuts, he fired Shas ministers and deputy ministers and the UTJ deputy ministers on the spot.

The public perceived this move as a display of resolve and leadership in handling the economy, conveying the message that the step was taken to prevent economic collapse and to demonstrate that the government is not a free-for-all in the area of economics. This marked another turning point for Sharon. After the firings his approval ratings shot sky-high, far beyond even his own expectations. The aftermath and the subsequent debasement of Shas, which eventually returned to the government with nothing to show for its pains, also played to Sharon's advantage.

And of course who can forget his shining success in keeping the Unity Government intact? Sharon's government passed many tests during the course of the year and saw many ups and downs, but he managed to keep the ship afloat, thereby winning over many important figures from Left and Center. As a seasoned politician, Sharon quickly recognized that the Labor Party was in a state of crisis, and he took full advantage of this.

Without a doubt Sharon is the Man of the Year in Israeli politics. It would be a safe bet to say he will win this title in the media simply because there are no challengers. His presence left no room for anybody else, conquering and dominating the entire political arena.

Binyamin Ben Eliezer

Security Minister Binyamin Ben Eliezer posted a mixed year. He was clearly the next most prominent political figure after Sharon. At the beginning of the year, defying all of the surveys and predictions, Ben Eliezer ran away with the Labor Party primaries and took over the party. Later he managed to maneuver past various obstacles and pitfalls set for him by fellow party members, proving he had the upper hand on the Labor Party.

Despite all of the attempts to unseat and block him from within, he also managed to keep the Labor Party in the government. Although many tried to get it out, Ben Eliezer guarded his seat zealously. After all he had gone through to secure it, he was not about to give up the Defense Ministry without a fight. Ben Eliezer was allied with Sharon and together they steered the nation in the direction they saw fit.

Within the Defense Ministry Ben Eliezer can also add some notches to his belt and look back on the past year with satisfaction. He can attribute the relative success in the war against terrorism to himself as much as to Ariel Sharon, and he also showed all those who scoffed when he became defense minister that he could do as good a job as the generals who preceded him.

Ben Eliezer's problem is that he is not perceived as capable of capturing the office of prime minister and leading the nation. Surveys also predict a decline in the Labor Party's sway in the next elections, which is blamed on Ben Eliezer.

Another problem placed on Ben Eliezer's doorstep--only at the end of the year, giving him next year to tackle it--was Mr. Amram Mitzne. The Haifa mayor entered national politics in a flurry. In one fell swoop he knocked Ben Eliezer out of his position as a shoo-in at the upcoming Labor Party primaries, leaving him a runner-up. Although Ben Eliezer has succeeded in closing the gap recently, he appears to be headed for defeat. Only his organizing skills, his ambition and his perseverance could save the day against an upstart who is leaving Ben Eliezer in the dust.

Binyamin Netanyahu

One of the big losers this year was former prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu. At the beginning of the year and even at the halfway point it appeared Netanyahu would beat Sharon in the next Likud Party primaries. For a long time Netanyahu led Sharon in Likud surveys by 20 percent and it seemed nothing would alter the situation. Netanyahu and his staffers walked around with smiles on their faces, waiting for the big day to arrive.

But meanwhile Sharon was getting little rest. He, too, read the opinion polls and took steps to change them. Defensive Shield, the Shas firings, the siege on Arafat, the capture of the Karine A, the assassinations of terrorist leaders, the torpedoing of Labor and the Left -- all raised Sharon's popularity not only in the general public, but among Likud voters as well, until eventually he achieved a turnaround. Sharon took the lead among Likud faithful in the polls. Although he held only a 5 percent advantage, this was a considerable achievement since he had been trailing by 20 percent.

Currently Sharon and Netanyahu are running about even in Likud polls, exchanging the lead frequently. If the current situation continues, every vote will count. The two contenders are in very different situations: as the incumbent prime minister, Sharon can take steps to improve his position, while all Netanyahu has at his disposal is his mouth and media exposure, but he knows well how to use both to his advantage.

Netanyahu could have been prime minister today instead of Sharon, but he passed up the opportunity. Now perhaps he has his regrets. Netanyahu did not believe Sharon would be able to hold out for so long, but his predictions have proven false. Sharon is holding up quite well in fact, and it appears Netanyahu could wind up paying a high price for passing up his chance when opportunity knocked.


All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.