Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

13 Tammuz 5761 - July 4, 2001 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Home and Family
Camp
by Chavi Rosenberg

It was their first summer in Eretz Yisrael. Like many other things, this summer sprang some interesting surprises, some of them pleasant, some of them less. Among the less bearable surprises was, for example, the sharav, the Israeli heat wave. The temperatures never climbed so high in Russia. "Drink, children, drink!" Valentina said over and again. "You've got to drink all day long!" The constant dryness in her mouth bothered her, and the beads of perspiration which dripped from her and the others were an even greater discomfort.

Michael was especially sensitive to odors and had always been. Summer was a most difficult experience for him. "I find it impossible to walk in the street or ride a bus," he complained. "The aggregate smell of perspiration is disgusting to me."

"There's no choice. You'll just have to get used to it," said Valentina for the millionth time since they had arrived in the country. "Remember that in Russia you couldn't stand the smell of wool," she reminded him. He smiled. The very thought of wool caused him to perspire and feel uneasy, and his perspiration again reminded him of the totally unpleasant odor of sweat in public places, and he found himself at the very starting point of the conversation...

Among the pleasant things was the subject of water. The cool, delicious impact with the sea or the swimming pool was an experience they had not known in Russia. Yonatan, for his part, was not especially enthusiastic about swimming, but Olga dived into the water freely, thrilled. She took a course and progressed at a rapid pace. "It was marvelous, fantastic, simply wonderful!" she declared each time she returned from the pool. "Summer in Eretz Yisrael is great!"

The long summer vacation was also a novelty for them. The summer vacation in Russia is much shorter. Valentina thought that the children needed this long break. They had exerted themselves to the utmost the whole year, both with regards to the language, socially and in all the other aspects of acclimatization for new immigrants. The time had now come to relax, ease off tensions and let go.

One evening, Valentina met an Israeli acquaintance of hers, Bracha Katz. Valentina noted immediately how bad she looked. She was pale, her eyes sunken, and an air of sadness or suffering had settled upon her in a very obvious manner. "Why don't you come up to me for a bit," she begged Valentina. Valentina agreed, hoping she might be able to hear what was disturbing her so, and perhaps help in some way.

Bracha prepared two cups of coffee and sliced some cake.

"Where are your daughters?" Valentina suddenly asked.

"They're in a `kemp' in Haifa," replied Bracha.

"`Kemp'? What's that?"

"It's an English word. How come you're not familiar with it?" Bracha wondered.

"Oh, I do understand English! I thought you were using the word in Hebrew and that it had a different connotation. There are all different kinds of camps, you know, so why didn't you simply use the Hebrew word machane? Isn't it the same thing?"

Bracha thought for a moment or two. "Listen, there are some words that are really the same thing in translation, yet, have another meaning. My daughters were not happy enough with the day camp the school ran. They wanted to go to a sleep-away camp. It's more exciting, much more of an experience. And, to be sure, so much more expensive."

Valentina was curious to hear more about the differences in activities, attractions and also, the variation in price. They talked about the summer, vacation and recreation. Now it became perfectly clear why Bracha looked so depressed. "We really can't afford it," she said over and over. "I took on some extra work this summer and my husband accepted a private student during his only free hour between the two kollelim he attends. And with it all, we won't be able to cover this dreadful expense."

"I can't begin to understand why you're trying to, to begin with," Valentina asked with utter simplicity.

"What can we do? Miriami's two best friends went to camp and she is not ready to give it up. And if Miriami goes, of course Dinale also has to go. And if the two girls go away to camp, the boys insist on going away as well to a special camp in the Galilee mountains. And that's not all of it. Besides the camp, before and after, there are expensive tiyulim, computer courses, entertainment, the pool and the ocean, performances to attend and so on. In short: a family like ours has to win a lottery in order to survive the summer. No exaggeration!" Bracha sighed.

"To tell you the truth, I don't understand what you're telling me. Every person has got to live according to his means. What you can't afford, you don't do. What difference does it make what Miriami's friends do? Whose paying for her camp, anyway -- they or you? My children told me about the school day camps, not about the machane, or camp, as you call it. And I said: `Sorry, kids. We have no money.' And that was the end of that."

"That's what you told them?"

"Yes, of course. What's wrong with it? Is it a disgrace not to have money?"

"No. It's no disgrace. But it never even occurred to me to include the children in our juggling of the family budget," answered Bracha.

"You needn't calculate your expense account together with them with detailed facts and figures. But if you're lacking money for something they want, what is more normal than telling them this truth? Look at the vicious cycle you've gotten yourself into. And for what? For the rest of their lives, they will have to learn to live within the limits of their means and possibilities, not according to other people's. There will always be people above them on the financial ladder, people who have more than they. What if Miriami's friend and her family decided to travel abroad? Would you let her go abroad as well?"

"No," Bracha answered quickly.

"So in any event, you'd have to stop the carousel at some point. So why not stop it at the most natural one -- the point where the money ends. You can go on outings in this area that will hardly cost you a grush. They can stay home and play games and occasionally go to the sea and the pool. They can cook up all kinds of interesting meals. There are lots and lots of nice things to keep them busy. And you know what? They can also get bored a little and it wouldn't be the end of the world! But you can't live beyond your means. That's a real tragedy."

Bracha listened thoughtfully. "Valentina, you want to hear something interesting? Your advice is absolutely simple and normal. But no one thought of telling us that yet!"

"Maybe it's because we're not yet used to this leisure society, this vacation culture. Perhaps it's because everything in this country is so new and exciting that we don't think big. It might also be that my children, boruch Hashem, are very easy going and receptive. Or... I don't really know myself what else..." she smiled.

"Maybe it's because you're Valentina," said Bracha, "and I truly thank you. You have no idea how much you've helped me. I hope that from now on it will be different."

*

Interesting, but the person who was left most taken up with her thoughts was Valentina. She couldn't, simply couldn't understand what motivated a woman like Bracha to become so driven by the desires of her children, or more accurately, her children's friends, when she did not have the financial means to afford them. Who said you had to keep up with the Cohens?

I am glad that Valentina did not meet me when she came home from her visit to Bracha, for, believe me, I wouldn't have known how to explain the nature of that `sickness' to her, except to describe to her how terribly contagious it was...

 

All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.