Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

2 Shevat 5765 - January 12, 2005 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

Opinion & Comment

Coalition Problems Continue

By E. Rauchberger

The new coalition has been set up, but Prime Minister Ariel Sharon's problems are far from over. On paper, all appears splendid with 64 coalition members—40 from the Likud, 19 from Labor, 5 from UTJ — and another 5 potential additions. The five waiting in the wing are three MKs from Am Echad which is slated to merge with Labor, and two independent MKs, Paritzky and Nudelman, who can be enlisted ad hoc should the need arise.

Yet despite these impressive numbers Sharon's main problem in the previous coalition remains the same: the rebels from his own party who oppose the disengagement plan. 13 Likud MKs signed a letter informing their UTJ colleagues they would not support setting up a government with Labor because the primary agenda would then be to carry out the disengagement plan.

This letter created a great storm in the political arena, particularly in the Likud. Sharon considered it a very grave matter, warning the members of the renegade group they are acting against the decisions of the Likud Convention and would topple the Likud government. All 13 voted against the government when it was approved on Monday.

The rebels stopped being intimidated by Sharon and his threats long ago and are prepared to do whatever it takes to torpedo the disengagement plan.

The new coalition is not going to have an easy time in the day-to-day life at the Knesset. In the Knesset committees the rebels will continue to cause trouble. Without them the coalition will not have a majority. Sharon's next move is to try to get Shas, which will give him a majority without them.

Of the plethora of Knesset committees three are crucial for any coalition: the Finance Committee, the House Committee and the Constitutional Committee, where without a majority a government cannot advance important legislative initiatives. In these three committees the opposition and the rebels have a majority and together they are in a position to sabotage the coalition, blocking legislative initiatives, funding transfers, etc.

An example of what the rebels, with the assistance of the opposition, can accomplish was seen recently in the Constitutional Committee, when approval could not be obtained for several paragraphs of the evacuation-compensation bill, despite support by Labor, Shinui and Yachad MKs. So what will happen in issues Shinui and Yachad don't support? The opposition will have an absolute majority.

In the Knesset plenum as well the coalition will not enjoy an automatic majority. The settlers will apply heavy pressure on the rebels not to assist the government, even in votes on less important and even trivial issues in order to undermine the government's stability as much as possible. Failures of this sort will invariably make the headlines once again, creating the impression the State of Israel lacks a stable government and has to lean on the far left in the form of Yachad.

Shas Next

This also explains why Sharon's next goal will be to bring Shas into the coalition. Sharon is well aware if he wants a stable government without having to rely on favors from the opposition he will have to have Shas join the government. If the peace process is revived following the election of Abu Mazzan, Shas will draw closer to the coalition.

To this end even Sharon is willing to grant Shas MKs voting freedom on the peace issue, i.e. they would be allowed to vote against the government on every vote associated with the disengagement plan, for even without them the disengagement plan has a solid majority due to the backing of Yachad and Shinui and the abstention of the Arab MKs.

The decision to bring Shas into the coalition appears to depend on how the new coalition operates. If the coalition runs smoothly and manages to overcome all of the obstacles, Shas will be rejected or brought in on the cheap. But if the coalition finds itself with daily problems, Shas' price tag will increase and Sharon will have to pay.

Even with UTJ, while at the beginning of the coalition negotiations Sharon demanded UTJ representatives commit to support every vote on the disengagement plan, including the evacuation-compensation law, in the end UTJ MKs were given voting freedom on matters of national policy.


All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.