Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

8 Av 5762 - July 17, 2002 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Home and Family
Social Pressure
by R. Chadshai

How should I answer?

"Ima, where are we going on vacation this year?"

"What do you mean by that? Who said we're going anywhere?"

"I don't mean right away. Sometime during bein hazmanim."

"Who said we're going away? We made no plans. You know I work during the school vacation and we don't usually go away, so why are you asking?"

"Because Riki told me they're going to a hotel in Netanya, Tzippy told me that this year they're going to rent an apartment in Tsfas and Yochi's family is switching apartments with a family in Yerusholayim. Not to forget Dassy, who's flying to the States to spend two weeks with her grandmother. So what about us? Aren't we going anywhere? Afterwards, all my friends talk about their experiences and when they ask where I went, what will I tell them?"

Without a scooter, I have nothing to do in the afternoon!

Tuvia came back from cheder and announced that he had nothing to do in the afternoon.

"But we have so many games! And what about all the friends you can play with in the yard?"

"All of my friends have scooters except me, and all they do is ride around. I also need a scooter!"

"A scooter? Whatever for? Don't you have a bike?"

"The bike is too heavy and clumsy. By the time I take it down and bring it back up, there's no time left for riding. Besides, there's hardly any place where I can ride. You told me yourself that it's dangerous to go in the street. A scooter is so much better. It's lighter and safer!"

"I still don't understand why you need a scooter. What will you do with it all afternoon?"

"All my friends have one. Look out the window and see them scooting around, having a great time. There aren't any kids with bikes downstairs."

It's hard for me, but I've simply got to do it!"

"I've got two simchas to go to tonight," fifteen- year- old Brachi announced.

"Really?" her mother asked in surprise.

"Avigail's brother is getting married tonight and Miri's sister is getting engaged!"

"Mazel tov! But what does that have to do with you?"

"She gave me a personal invitation."

"But it's only Avigail's brother. You don't know him. Anyway, you're hardly close to her, either. Why do you feel you have to go?"

"But the whole class is going!"

"I think that's going too far. I think it's an intrusion when the chosson's kid sisters each bring their whole class. And he does have a big family, if I'm not mistaken. Won't it be much too crowded? There won't be room for the kalla's friends and family to dance."

"Ima, believe me, I have a test tomorrow which I didn't even study for. It's really hard for me to go, but I'm making the effort. I have to. Everyone else is going!"

SOCIAL PRESSURE

Who hasn't encountered this phenomenon? Social pressure puts stress on the child and on the parents as well, forcing them to give in. Often, children have not thought through whether they need something or if they are doing something merely because of social pressure, and it seems to them, or so they convince themselves, that this is something they really want or need. It is impossible to ignore the influence of the peer group on the child's behavior and desires, especially among adolescents, and it is important to know how to relate to it.

The effect of obligations

First of all, it is important to know that this phenomenon has a positive side to it, and we will discuss this first. Parents don't realize how grateful they should be for the fact that there is social pressure. There are many positive modes of behavior that children get used to as a result of peer pressure. Chazal related to this as one of the factors which prevent people from sinning (in public): people are afraid to being seen by others, afraid of what they might say or think of them.

Social pressure has many positive aspects, when we're talking about a positive society, of course. For example: yeshiva boys are influenced for the good by the friendly atmosphere in their peer group, which leads to an improvement in their middos. They may be motivated to greater diligence by a positive atmosphere in the beis midrash. In the beginning, their motives may not be pure and they might be just trying to fit in, but eventually these good traits will become part and parcel of their personality.

Seminary girls, even those who don't come from Torah homes, eventually express the same desire as the other girls -- to get married and build a home based on Torah principles. (If we glance back a few dozens years, we can see that marrying a Ben Torah was definitely not a priority in those days.) We must admit that a good part of this turnabout is due to the efforts expended by the seminarys, but a good part is also due to social pressure. The girls, even from non-religious homes, are influenced by the general atmosphere and their ideal is to marry a Ben Torah like their friends.

It is important to note that adolescents and pre- adolescents improve their self-image by adapting themselves to the standards of their peer group. In most instances, this desire is positive, because we're dealing with accepted standards.

Different style?

At a certain stage, parents of adolescents might feel frustrated by their teenager's conduct. They notice the tendency to imitate certain fashions, and extreme behavior on the part of their son or daughter. These might be a bit overwhelming and they worry about their adolescent child, especially if he's the oldest. And if the situation is like this now, what will it be like later?

But parents have to know that young people try to discover their unique identities, and this is how adolescents develop themselves. Many parents wonder where all their hard work as parents got lost. "Why is our daughter so demanding? What happened to the example she sees at home and our own modest style of living?" Or "Why is he going to bed so late? What about keeping up with the rules and regulations we worked so hard on?" and so on.

It seems the teenager is now trying to develop a different personality and style, that he wants to imitate his peer group, but we shouldn't be upset over the changes during this interim period, nor should we despair of the positive influence absorbed by them over the years because they do take all this into account, even if it doesn't seem so on the outside. For the moment, they are testing everything anew, and most of them will eventually go back to their `old' selves, strengthened in their convictions.

Personal example and the generation gap

Before trying to help our children overcome unjust social pressure, let us examine our own personal example to them. Sometimes we don't realize how we ourselves give in to certain pressures. One woman told how a neighbor of hers had spoken for years against the use of microwaves, in principle. After some of her children got married and started using microwaves and lauding their practical side (especially for working mothers, whereby children can warm up their food themselves), she gave in and bought one for the house.

After checking into our own personal example, we should listen to our children and weigh the pros and cons with sensitivity and understanding. It could be that the parents compare the child to themselves as young people, and forget that times and ideas have changed a least a bit. A mother could wonder, "Why does she need a different outfit for every simcha? I didn't have a quarter of the wardrobe she has, and I wouldn't have dreamed of asking for more!" Or "What is this craze of going to every simcha? In my day, only the kalla's best friends would come to the wedding!" Although we don't have to give in to every demand, it pays to consider the fact that times have changed and certain accepted social mores have come into fashion. These may be hard to avoid, but appropriate limits should certainly be set.

If after checking the two above mentioned points, i.e. our personal example and the generation gap, we still feel that our child's demands are unreasonable and s/he is giving in too much to social pressure, we have to try and help him out.

Next week: How to Overcome Social Pressure. A five point program

 

All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.