Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

19 Adar II 5765 - March 30, 2005 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Home and Family

The Hide of an Elephant
by A. Ross

Someone showed me a piece of elephant's hide recently, and it was a real eye-opener. The skin is about half an inch thick, and with one or two wire like hairs embedded in their follicles, it was a truly awesome sight. When we say someone is thick-skinned, we mean that he is insensitive. When we say he has the hide of an elephant, we imply that he is indifferent to everything and everyone.

Children on the whole want to please. Whether it is in dealings with their parents, teachers, siblings or classmates, they learn the social norms fairly quickly in their young lives, and try to fulfill their obligations, knowing that it is for their own benefit in the long run. Not all children jump up when they are called. Nor do all children put down the interesting book in which they are engrossed, in order to run and help Mommy. They just feel that what they are doing is more important at the moment. They might get reprimanded, and yet they might repeat their lack of obedience. This is part of growing up. However, there are some children who are extremely difficult to handle. They do not 'tick' in the way others do. Neither rewards nor punishments move them. Admonishments leave them cold, as does praise. They seem to enjoy picking a fight, both at home and in school, and are allergic to authority of any kind.

There are some babies who are so obstinate even before the age of twelve months, that parents soon learn to avoid a tantrum by yielding to their wishes whenever possible. Some parents decide that they cannot let this little tyrant rule the roost, and will handle him very firmly, hoping that they will teach him to toe the line. Others, particularly mothers who have to face the awful consequences when the child is thwarted, decide to be over lenient. They will offer bribes which may work for a day or less. Both ways are counter- productive.

In the first instance, when a parent decides to be severe and authoritarian, the child seems to be impervious to punishment. If you deprive him of a treasured possession, he might hit out at a younger sibling or throw the rest of his (and the family's) toys out of the window. This sounds extreme, but has happened! He will gradually become completely defiant as he becomes physically stronger, and do exactly as he wishes both inside and outside the house.

On the other hand, if he is treated too leniently without any limits, so that he has no opportunity to throw a tantrum or smash things, he will become completely out of hand, impossible to control. Moreover, in spite of his uncaring attitude to all around him, this lack of limits will add to his feeling of being unwanted, and different. He is not nearly as insensitive as he pretends to be.

Until this child was born, the parents knew they were in authority. It was a happy harmonious family, with ups and downs no doubt, but the children were growing up true to expectation. Now this 'bad' child has arrived, and nobody quite knows how to handle him. He looks you in the eye in defiance, as if he were an adult himself. The more you try to talk to him and reason with him, the stonier his expression, as if he weren't even listening. Quite so, he is not listening, his ears are closed to reason. As soon as parents realize that they have been blessed with a child like this, they will have to come to terms with the fact that they cannot treat him as they handled the others. Above all, they have to agree with each other and not let the child manipulate them.

If he were autistic, or had Down's syndrome, or any other handicap with which children are born into the world, parents would accept him sooner or later for what he is. They would try to educate him to achieve his maximum potential, and would tell the siblings that they have a special neshoma entrusted to them.

However, this obstinate child who seems to have such a thick skin and is so belligerent towards the world at large, has no handicap. He is causing havoc in the house (and in school). He needs even more love than all the others, but that is easier said than done. He needs freedom above all else, but then you will never know where he is. A trampoline is a very useful piece of equipment for him, but unfortunately these children are terribly possessive. Thus, if you do manage to acquire one, he should help you formulate the rules. Ask him what time is best for him. This is a suggestion, and like all suggestions, it may not work.

When the child has committed some crime, there is no point in talking to him at all. While he is still very little, Mother can manage to hold him tight, to prevent him from doing further mischief. As he grows bigger, Father will have to restrain him. Do not show any anger, however difficult this may be, just hold him in a bear hug so that he cannot move. From experience, this is hard both physically and emotionally. One of these boys whose parents locked him in the bathroom in desperation, put the plug into the bath and turned on both faucets! He emerged defiant and victorious.

Any parent who is trying to educate one of these children, can elaborate on smashed doors and windows, among other stories. However, there are some quiet periods when the child does not feel that anyone is trying to tell him what to do. That is the time to speak to him, explaining what you are trying to achieve. Not with any animosity, but quite clearly. For example, 'We are not prepared to let you do such and such. Nor do we allow you to speak in this way. We are your parents and feel that our way is the correct way. We are not trying to boss you around in any way, but feel that this is for your good and also for our good.' All children need boundaries, however difficult it is to enforce them. The message will get across that the parents really mean what they say. That they love him as he is, but that they have set limits on his behavior.

In very extreme cases, some relative or close friend, who loves the child and whom he trusts, might agree to let him come to stay, either for weekends, or even for an extended period of time. It will have to be someone who does not live close enough for the child to abscond, and go back home. I have seen this work very successfully with a boy who now regards his aunt's home in a different town, as his second, or even his first, home. He is much calmer there with no competition for the love and attention he so badly craves, apart from two baby cousins. He sees that other people besides his parents have the same values. Nobody tells him what to do, so he goes to bed when he feels tired. He does not wash as frequently as he should, but nobody remarks on it. He has been there for about five years, and because of his improved behavior there, he feels better about himself, and so conforms more easily when he is at home. No doubt all the prayers which were said for him have played a part in the improvement too.

 

All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.