Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

22 Adar II 5763 - March 26, 2003 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Home and Family


BOOK REVIEW
Three Special Days

by Yaakov Meir Strauss
Published by Feldheim, Reviewed by Judith Weil

Three Special Days by Rabbi Yaakov Meir Strauss is a work of historical fiction set during Second Temple times. It describes ten-year-old Naftali's pre- Pesach journey to Jerusalem with his parents, older brother and baby sister and his experiences once he arrives there. The publication serves as a vehicle for the teaching of a wealth of different laws, customs, opinions and social norms and the reader accompanies the family as it prepares for the yom tov, visits the Beis Hamikdosh, brings sacrifices, celebrates the seder and eats the korbon Pesach.

The book includes diagrams showing the design of the Beis Hamikdosh and illustrations that enable the reader to envision many details of life during the Second Temple period. These include the Beis Hamikdosh layout and furnishings, the architecture of the buildings and the design of the clothing people wore. References and sources are provided in footnotes and as such, they aid the serious student without disturbing the smooth flow of the text.

Three Special Days, the first book in the "Naftali in the Beis Hamikdosh" series, originally appeared in Hebrew under the title, HaZechiya Hagodolah. The second book in the series, Mul Kisei Hakovod, which describes day- to-day life in the Temple, is not yet available in English.

The family journeys to Jerusalem by donkey cart and picks up a fellow traveler whose conversation proves a major source of knowledge -- to the reader that is. Little is new to the very knowledgeable characters in the book! Naftali does erroneously suggest, however, regarding the animals being brought to Jerusalem for various sacrificial purposes, that they be hitched to the wagon. He is soon told that the Sages forbade this in case these animals would help the donkey pull the burden, something that would constitute a transgression of the Torah's prohibition of kilayim (mixed species).

As Naftali nears Jerusalem, we learn that Jerusalem residents were forbidden to make a profit on the Sholosh Regolim hospitality. We hear how the residents of Jerusalem congregated outside the gates in order to invite the visitors to the city to stay in their homes.

In this book, Reb Asher, an old yeshiva friend of Naftali's father, met the family and asked them to join him and his family.

We read how Naftali's family went to the Beis Hamikdosh and how his mother brought a post-natal sin offering of a turtledove. We feel the hustle and bustle as he walks through the streets and encounters merchants drawing loud notice to their wares -- matzos, pomegranate- wood spits for roasting the paschal lambs, candles for searching for chometz and so on. We even accompany him as he visits the Announcing Stone -- the equivalent of what we today would call a lost-property depot.

We are conscious that the story is set in springtime and when we view a hill that is white as snow, we realize that since there is no snow at this time of the year, the whiteness must come from the fleece of thousands upon thousands of young sheep.

We come across a social situation that existed in days gone by: Naftali's father does not buy sufficient matzos to last throughout Pesach. He prefers to wait until chol hamoed, after the Omer sacrifice has been brought and flour will have gone down in price. This does not occur nowadays. While the halochos regarding the date of the Omer still exist, few people bake matzos on chol hamoed, and fewer still use flour from the new post- Omer harvest.

It is impossible to list all the many laws and customs we encounter. Some, like the discussion about whether matzos can be purchased with maaser sheni money, do not apply today. Others, like annulling the chometz and relating the story of the Exodus, will be familiar to today's generation. Events within the Temple itself are totally outside our experience.

The publication was clearly a labor of love. It is written in simple language and is a relaxing read that belies the huge amount of information packed into its pages. The facts this book contains cannot be remembered and absorbed after a single reading and it needs to be read and reread. Its contents will fall further and further into place as youngsters learn the relevant Torah verses, mishnayos and halochos.

The blurb on the back cover of the book states: "Young readers are invited to join Naftali and his family to experience `Three Special Days' -- the 12th, 13th and 14th of Nisan -- in this very special book. Celebrate Pesach with Naftali at the time of the second Beis Hamikdosh. Find out what happens when a mouse is seen on the Temple Mount. Meet the members of Naftali's chabura who will all spend seder night together. Catch a glimpse of the Sanhedrin in session and peek into the Chamber of Secrecy with Naftali and his friend Aharon. Walk through the crowded marketplace with Naftali and his father as they buy wine, matzos and new pottery for the holiday and choose maror from the five different kinds of bitter herbs. Learn the laws of the offering brought in the Temple and join Naftali as his brother Yitzchak slaughters the korbon Pesach.

"Author Rabbi Yaakov Meir Strauss brings the days of the Second Temple to life with his exciting story, extensively annotated and enhanced with maps and diagrams of each structure in the Beis Hamikdash, as well as with charming illustrations."

Certainly, this is a book well worth reading, and well worth studying, but that said, I nevertheless have two reservations.

The first is that this book is not for everybody. This is not a publication for the spiritually immature. We live in a generation that has transient values of its own and not everyone appreciates that the Torah message transcends twenty- first century spiritual correctness. Many people will not be ready to learn of restrictions as to who can eat the korbon Pesach, of some of the punishments that could occur, and so forth. This is a book suitable only for people who are highly committed to the Jewish way of life.

My second reservation is more personal. I am a Jerusalem housewife who dreams of the day when she will be able to welcome family and friends coming to the Holy City for the Shalosh Regalim. Readers are supposed to identify with young Naftali. I personally identify more with the hostess who received the family into her home. We do not learn much about her, not even her name. But what we do learn is amazing.

"Mrs. Reb Asher", for want of a better title, has six children of her own and expects her parents for the yom tov, but she nevertheless puts up three additional families, not only during yom tov itself, but starting already during the busy pre-Pesach period. Her guests try not to make too much trouble but, as we all know, the nicest visitors create extra work.

She prepares meals, allows Naftali to tie a lamb to the foot of his bed and finds her home is the scene of a loud, excited Torah discourse. She is even faced with a situation whereby one set of guests who traveled to Eretz Yisroel all the way from Babylon take the opportunity of their coming to Jerusalem to bring a thanksgiving offering of eighty loaves (most of them chometz) and two lambs. Seventy-two of the loaves and a large proportion of the meat had to be eaten in Reb Asher's home during the course of a single evening. And because the family could not manage this alone, even with the help of the sleep-in guests, they invited the neighbors to help them eat the bread and mutton. It must have required a large number of neighbors to get through that amount of food!

It wouldn't have been easy at Shavuos time or at Succos time, but just before Pesach!

In spite of all this, she babysits for Naftali's little sister, apparently willingly and with a smile, so that Naftali's mother can go to the Beis Hamikdosh.

Personally, I'd like to see a book written from Mrs. Reb Asher's angle. I'd like to know how she did it. Our Sages say that it was in the merit of righteous women that our forefathers were redeemed from Egypt. It appears that the women who lived during the Temple periods could not have been far behind!

The reader can identify with the final sentences on the back cover, "Three Special Days awakens a yearning for our Holy Temple. May such yearning bring about our Redemption, speedily in our days."

 

All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.