Dei'ah veDibur - Information & Insight
  

A Window into the Chareidi World

22 Adar II 5763 - March 26, 2003 | Mordecai Plaut, director Published Weekly
NEWS

OPINION
& COMMENT

OBSERVATIONS

HOME
& FAMILY

IN-DEPTH
FEATURES

VAAD HORABBONIM HAOLAMI LEINYONEI GIYUR

TOPICS IN THE NEWS

HOMEPAGE

 

Produced and housed by
Shema Yisrael Torah Network
Shema Yisrael Torah Network

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Home and Family


Contrariness
by A. Ross, M.Ed.

Most people with toddlers and growing children have encountered the `terrible twos.' Children of this age are not short of love and affection, and love their mother/father as much as any baby loves anyone beside himself. It is just the age.

"Self/ 'lone/ I can/ nowanna/ no." Anything Mommy suggests is NO even if he is desperate to comply. For example, if she says, "Go and get your coat so we can go out," he will run in the opposite direction, yet five minutes later, he will be screaming to go out. At the end of the day, his mother feels she has been battling with him all day (and she has!). She may have three or four other pre-school children who, together, are less trouble than this one child who rules the roost and wears her out.

There is no satisfactory translation for the word davka, although `contrary' or `on purpose' is similar [while `for spite' is way off]. He doesn't even want you to give in to him. All children need boundaries to know how far they can go and they test you out. This child is testing his independence. He is not trying to annoy or even to call attention to himself. He refuses to be fed, and insists on drinking from a cup 'lone even though much of the food and drink misses his mouth. He won't let you strap him into the stroller and screams hysterically when you attempt to do so.

So what are you going to do about the little rebellious tyrant? These children are extremely sagacious; nevertheless, at this age, mothers are still cleverer. It is easy enough to fool small children and to distract their attention. Most things are not worth a fight. If he insists on dressing himself, let him. You might be surprised at the amount he manages to do. If his pullover is back-to-front, you can either give a surreptitious little tug or just leave it. Does it matter?

In fact, most things are not really important. Thus, if you can avoid confrontation, do so. Naturally, there are some points which are not up for discussion. Strangely enough, most normal children, however contrary they are, do not insist on chillul Shabbos. They somehow pick up by osmosis which things are essential or non-negotiable, and where they can insist on their own way.

Leave the stroller near the front door and take your own coat off, going back into the kitchen as if you have no intention of going out. He will be pulling at you and asking to go out within a minute. Now you can bargain with the little despot. "If you sit in the stroller, we can go. Otherwise we have to stay home." In most cases, he will comply immediately.

There are those who rebel against the bath, yet once they are in, they refuse to come out. This is not a case of fear; the child is just contrary. Distract him and pop him in. If he refuses to come out, pull out the plug, gather up the toys and make as if to leave the bathroom. Make quite sure the taps are turned off really tightly. Then distract him with, "Let's go and see the..." as you lift him out.

There is no doubt that some children are naturally more docile and compliant than others. They display instant obedience, are often even overanxious to please and never seem to reach the rebellious age. And just in the same way, some teenagers do not seem to have the common teenage problems, which seem to pass them by as they mature sweetly and gracefully into adults. Indeed, incredible as it may seem to those families where each child goes through an acute phase of rebelliousness at some time or other, these angel children exist, but are not the subject of this article!

By the same token, there are some who are extremely difficult to deal with. These may be the ones who will eventually be diagnosed as suffering from Attention Deficit Disorder or other problems, although it certainly doesn't have to be so. They may just be particularly lively and active children. If this independent davkanik child wants to help you in the house, try your best not to discourage him. He cannot do the ironing, but he can certainly use the vacuum cleaner, although this will be hard work for you. You have to pick up all small parts of toys or stray pieces of jigsaw from the floor and must make quite sure that large things are not lying around. Otherwise, your helper might say, "I tried to feed the vacuum cleaner with a glove, but it choked and now it isn't working any more."

You might venture to let him mop floors, small areas at a time. Admittedly you may have to change him from top to toe if he is eager to do the dishes, and redo the dishes and wash the floor after him in the bargain. [DON'T do this when he is around, so as not to insult his efforts.] Lavish the praise and he will feel happy and not frustrated. He has spent half an hour or more without fighting the adult world. He has been a part of it. Some of his rebellious behavior seemingly stems from frustration, say the experts. There are so many things he would like to do; they look so easy and interesting. Yet he is either not allowed to do them or he cannot quite manage.

As mentioned before, avoid confrontation. If possible, give the child a choice. Do you want to go in the bath first -- or after Yanky? A child of two or three knows quite well that he has been given a choice and has decided for himself. Older siblings will copy you and learn how to get 'round the child without causing a scene.

One word of comfort to all those mothers who feel they are at the end of their tether. By the time he is five, the child will have mastered many social skills. He will have learned that there are other people in the world besides himself, and he will have become quite human. But do not rejoice too soon. Rebelliousness recurs a few years later, when a child becomes a teenager.

Nevertheless, take heart. These years too, will pass; they don't last forever. If you have been able to weather the storms without too much animosity (and argument, and there is bound to be friction) you will have a well-balanced son or daughter who will thank you for a pleasant childhood, and who will begin the whole cycle again with his/her own children.

 

All material on this site is copyrighted and its use is restricted.
Click here for conditions of use.